Cell-free hemoglobin (Hb) enhances the oxidation-related toxicity associated with inflammation, ischemia, and hemolytic disorders. Hb is highly vulnerable to oxidative damage, and irreversible structural changes involving iron/heme oxidation, heme-adduct products, and amino acid oxidation have been reported. Specific structural features of Hb, such as unconstrained α−chains and molecular size, determine the efficiency of interactions between the endogenous Hb scavengers haptoglobin (Hp) and CD163. Using HPLC, mass spectrometry, and Western blotting, we show that H₂O₂-mediated Hb oxidation results in the formation of covalently stabilized globin multimers, with prominent intramolecular crosslinking between α−globin chains. These structural alterations are associated with reduced Hp binding, reduced CD163 interaction, and severely impaired endocytosis of oxidized Hb by the Hp-CD163 pathway. As a result, when exposed to oxidized Hb, CD163-positive HEK293 cells and human macrophages do not increase hemeoxygenase-1 (HO-1) expression, the physiological anti-oxidative macrophage response to Hb exposure. Failed Hb clearance, inadequate HO-1 expression, and the subsequent accumulation of oxidatively damaged Hb species might thus contribute to pathologies related to oxidative stress.